10T Studios
← All articles

Blog

Planner, shared calendar or ERP module: how to choose

6 min read

Photo: charlesdeluvio / Unsplash

Short answer

A shared calendar is enough when you schedule people or places without complicated rules. An ERP module is worth it when the ERP already runs the company and the plan has to reach stock and accounting. A custom planner makes sense when the plan follows rules a ready-made tool does not know, or when the module is too rigid or too expensive for them. Which of the three you are depends on the three questions below.

01The three questions that decide it

  • 01How many rules does the plan have? If the only one is “they must not overlap”, a calendar is enough. Add availability, qualifications, vehicles, travel time and job priority, and a calendar cannot police them.
  • 02Who sees and changes the plan? If only the manager does, nearly anything copes. If people in the field must see and confirm it, and some changes come from them, you need a tool that can carry that.
  • 03Where does the plan go next? If hours and materials turn into an invoice or a stock issue, the plan has to be connected to those, otherwise the data is retyped again.

02A shared calendar

The cheapest and quickest way, and for a small company often entirely sufficient. A Google or Microsoft calendar with one calendar per person or resource handles bookings, sharing and reminders without any new software.

It runs out where rules are needed: it cannot warn that someone lacks the certificate, that the van is in for repair or that there is no time for the drive. And getting data from a calendar into an invoice is awkward.

03An ERP module

If you already use an ERP and its planning module covers your work, it is a sensible choice, because plan and actuals live in one system. Check whether the module is part of your package or a separate licence, and what setting it up costs.

The weak point tends to be rigidity. When your work does not match how the vendor imagined planning, people get used to planning outside the ERP — and the plan drifts back into a spreadsheet, now with a licence attached.

04A custom planner

It pays off when the planning rules are your competitive edge or ready-made tools do not know them, and neither the calendar nor the ERP fits. A first usable version comes out like other internal systems, in the €2,000–10,000 range, with the lower end applying to a planner with a handful of clear rules.

It is also the most expensive option to maintain, because you own the planning rules. If they change seasonally, the system has to change with them.

05What a wrong choice costs

Most often not money but a parallel world: the official plan in the tool and the real one in a spreadsheet or the group chat. Once that happens the plan stops reflecting the work and nobody trusts it.

That is why it is worth trying the cheaper option first with one group of people and watching what they work around. Those workarounds are the brief for the next step.

Frequently asked

When is a shared calendar enough?
When you schedule people or resources without complicated rules — it is enough that bookings do not overlap — and the plan does not have to flow automatically into invoicing or stock.
When does a custom planner beat an ERP module?
When the plan follows rules the module does not know, when it is too rigid or expensive, or when you do not use an ERP. A first version comes out in the €2,000–10,000 range.
Can I start with a calendar and move to a planner later?
Yes, and it is sensible. The job and date data can be carried over, and whatever people worked around in the calendar is the exact brief for the planner.

Related

More articles